/a/ - Anime

Anime&Manga


New Reply
Name
×
Email
Subject
Message
Files Max 5 files32MB total
Tegaki
Password
[New Reply]


580fe770d81827dbbb18a30649cabd07c421364f0983e18f1e35ddc8ec5b4444.png
[Hide] (808KB, 1280x720)
There isn't a single good anime adaptation of a VN. As I am reading Muramasa, no matter how much I would like it to have an anime, I realize they are going to cut out all the inner monologue and narration and dumb it down to some shonenshit
Replies: >>17 >>20 >>24 >>26 >>217
>dumb it down to some shonenshit
Muramasa is basically naruto with mechs
>>9 (OP) 
And that's a good thing, fuck people who refuse to read. That's some gay retard shit.
>how do we adapt this visual novel into a seasonal anime that only lasts 5 percent of the  actual read time of the visual novel?
>cut off the entire story outside of a few main things that happen. that won't piss people off because they don't read anyways
>oh yeah btw  all that other stuff  that's part of the visual novel is non cannon now
>>9 (OP) 
The old Key VN adaptions like Clannad were pretty good, but an anime will almost always be inferior to a VN since the mediums have their own strengths.
Replies: >>22
>>20
This. A 100% accurate vn adaptation would still be shit since they are different mediums that have different approaches that don't mesh well together. 
> but an anime will almost always be inferior to a VN 
I agree only when talking about anime that are vn adaptations since I like plenty of anime that would lose their charm if they were to receive a vn adaptation. It works both ways.
Replies: >>25
>>9 (OP) 
Steins;Gate was good, yes the VN was infinitely better but that's a given since it's the original work.
instead of lamenting Muramasa lacking an anime, you hsou should be angry that steam banned it.
>>22
I wanted a KonoSuba visual novel sometime ago. And only just realized there is one and it's only 13 hours long so there is no real story it's just random scenarios and shit you would see in the show.
>>9 (OP) 
btw did you know Muramasa was written by Urobutcher under a pin name? I did my research and I believe it.
Replies: >>32
>>26
Doubt it uro chokes on longer stories his best stuff is super short from experience
>psycho-pass
Replies: >>34 >>36
>>32
Read Kikokugai, and you will see it immediately.
>>32
>uro chokes on longer stories his best stuff is super short from experience
nips theories that he copied most of Muramasa from Dies Irae which is why in the first place he used a pen name. and btw the main plot of the VN particularly the Rokuhara shogunate, is taken from Taira clan tyranny over Japan, but the names switched to Ashikaga for some reason.
>>9 (OP) 
Utawarerumono blocks your path
[New Reply]
11 replies | 1 file | 6 UIDs
Connecting...
Show Post Actions

Actions:

Captcha:

Select the solid/filled icons
- news - rules - faq -
jschan 1.4.1